As a creator or performer needing self-discipline, structure, and the highest possible standards, the inner critic is meant to be our friend. So how did it become a foe?
The inner critic is a great ally when it comes to getting us back into the practice room, or back to the writing table. When it understands what our true ideals are, it will faithfully help us serve them.
When it has no idea what our ideals are, however, it will do its best to take over with the only material available: the inherited beliefs handed down by our parents, teachers, peers, and society as a whole. It will naturally bring us into line with what is familiar, known, and expected. Its entire job is to please the people around us in order to keep the support of our families, friends, and the "tribe." In the eyes of the inner critic, this guarantees both survival and belonging—and because those two needs are so vital, it is no wonder the inner critic holds so much leverage over us.
Fear of leaving those expectations behind can keep us from ever stepping out of our comfort zone or questioning our so-called limitations. Yet staying safely in our lane, creatively speaking, without developing our own inner ideal, will sooner or later cause anxiety.
Pleasing others is clearly central to human life—research has shown that connectedness is a vital factor in physical and emotional health. However, when pleasing others means a disconnection from the self, anxiety begins to take hold. The mask goes on, and we walk onto the stage without ever really taking it off, trying desperately to produce the sounds and impressions that we learned were wanted.
But what if we never actually expressed anything that was true for us in those moments of being seen?
Our deeper desire is actually to be accepted for whom we really are—our authentic self, our truth. To be seen, heard, and accepted as we are is a truly profound healing for anxiety. Beneath the surface noise, quiet questions are waiting to be answered:
“Am I safe?”
“Am I worthy of love, respect, and acknowledgement for my contribution?”
“Do I have a purpose?”
“Does my talent carry something truly worthwhile to communicate—something of my essence that only I can produce?”
“What is my own ideal? I’ve spent so many years following a prescribed path that I’ve lost touch with being present to myself.”
When we finally pause and listen beneath the noise of the inner critic, we begin to discover that our own ideal was there all along - waiting for us to let go of the mask and trust what is already inside us.
Dr Anna McDonald is a violinist, kamancheh player, and performance coach based in Sydney and Canberra. Through Attunement Performance Coaching, she helps musicians, creatives, and professionals unravel performance anxiety and reconnect with their authentic voice. Learn more about online and in-person sessions at attunementsessions.com.